The moment the opening crawl hit the screen and that first triumphant blast of brass filled the theater was the moment I knew that Star Wars Episode IX was going to be a disappointment. I had gone into the cinema that day hopeful for at least a decent, reasonably satisfying conclusion to the "Skywalker Saga," and, having kept somewhat aware of leaked plot points I thought that JJ Abrams might manage to deliver on some of the hype surrounding the film. However, with that opening chord and that yellow, all caps font scrolling up the screen comes the weight of over four decades of beloved mythos and all the expectations of one of the most significant cultural phenomena of modern times. It was when I saw that first text, "Episode IX," and heard Williams' now forty-two year old score that I knew I was going to be disappointed, that this film could not possibly live up to it's predecessors. It was then that I finally admitted to myself that these new Star Wars films were always destined to fall short of holding a candle to what came before.
Over the next 140 minutes, the film seemed to answer me: "Amazing. Every word of what you just thought was wrong."
Beginning in the first few moments and continuing onward until the end, The Rise of Skywalker just feels like a Star Wars film. Of the Disney era outings, it's certainly the most reminiscent of the classic and prequel films - and I don't mean that it lifts from them in the way that The Force Awakens is often regarded as having taken from A New Hope. There might be a few plot elements here or there that one might consider to be especially similar to events in The Return of the Jedi, but by and large this film is its own.
No, The Rise of Skywalker feels like Star Wars in its tone, in its themes, and in its characters. The best way to put it may be that if The Force Awakens seemed like an attempt to make a film that commemorates the Star Wars of old and The Last Jedi seemed like an attempt to make a film that moved on from the Star Wars of old, The Rise of Skywalker seems like a film that simply builds on and continues the Star Wars of old. In other words, it's the first film of the Disney era that really feels like the next chapter in Lucas' story rather than one which is just offering remarks on that story as if it were some old relative to be remembered or laid to rest.
This doesn't mean that there is not some fan service in The Rise of Skywalker. There certainly is, but it's fan service done well. This film is packed with references which honor moments and characters from the previous films without feeling out of place, superfluous, or tacked on. This may be because rather than trying to treat those beloved moments or characters as a kind of fodder for easter eggs or cameos the way that Episode VII, and to a lesser degree Episode VIII, did, The Rise of Skywalker looks back in order to fulfill arcs and to pay off on the emotional investments that those earlier films made. For example, there are a couple of scenes involving C-3PO and R-2D2 which very much evoke memories of these characters from as far back as their first scenes in the Tunisian desert in 1977, but here The Rise of Skywalker uses these moments to bring a kind of emotional closure to the characters, a catharsis which draws meaning from those previous eight films rather than simply pointing to them in some kind of ostensibly clever reference.
As for the new characters introduced in The Force Awakens, there is no question that The Rise of Skywalker makes the best use of them and gives them the most genuine character development out of their three films. Characters like Poe and Finn, badly underutilized and left to stagnate or to repeat already completed character arcs in the previous films are finally able to shine. It helps that for the first time we actually get to see all of our heroes together for most of the film. One of the things that made the original Star Wars films successful was the dynamic of the various main characters playing off one another as the plot moved them from place to place. Until The Rise of Skywalker, the new generation of heroes hadn't really had a chance to do that. This film provides that chance and pulls it off well. It also handles the headliners much better. Rey finally feels like a fully realized character complete with weaknesses and personality that shows some evidence of having developed in all those years before we first met her on Jakku. She was certainly the most interesting character in either of the other two sequel films, but given what those films did with everyone else that doesn't say as much about her as it otherwise would. In The Rise of Skywalker she feels much more well rounded, almost like the difference between (if the cross-franchise reference can be forgiven) the difference between a season one Star Trek: The Next Generation character and the same character from the show's final season. The film even manages to do something with Kylo Ren that is much deeper than either of the two extremes we saw from him in previous films. Most importantly, all of these improvements feel natural; I never felt like I was being shown a scene just to make up for the inadequacy of some other film.
This film also does a much better job of incorporating the older heroes than the previous films. Where in Episodes VII and VIII Han Solo, Chewbacca, Luke, and to a lesser degree Leia felt at times more like transcendent legends who were just there to guide or inspire the new heroes, here Chewbacca finally feels like one of the gang, Leia feels like a peer to the new characters (which is especially amazing given the constraints that Carrie Fisher's death placed on the production of this film), and even Luke (minor spoiler?) comes across in a way that just works better than in the previous films. When Lando shows up, he never feels like someone so much larger than life that he can't fit with everybody else. (As an aside, Lando's character is one of the most uplifting parts of this film and I don't think anyone in the theater got away without smiling at his scenes.)
The Rise of Skywalker is far and away the most thematic of the sequel trilogy and this is one major way that the film feels more at home among the original films than among its more immediate predecessors. The first six films of the franchise, to one degree or another, were thematic; the better of them had an almost literary quality. In The Rise of Skywalker, there are several themes, two of which stand out very clearly: first, that a person is not defined by their identity, and second, that a person is never alone when they stand up for what is right. (There is a third that is worth listing here, but due to the risk of revealing a major spoiler I will omit it here). What really stands out to me is that these are the kinds of themes which transcend the confines of whatever conceits exist in a given story and so elevate the story to something greater than the sum of its parts. Without getting into a lengthy diversion, I will say that the thematic quality of this film is one of the reasons I think that in the long run it will stand the test of time along with predecessors like The Empire Strikes Back.
Before closing, it would be remiss not to address this film's relationship with The Last Jedi. It is no secret that film was extremely divisive, with some regarding it as the second best film of the franchise and others considering it an unforgivable offense against all that has ever been good in Star Wars. It is also no secret that The Rise of Skywalker is widely regarded as having taken efforts to walk back or to "fix" things which many fans disliked about that film. There is no question that on some points The Rise of Skywalker does look at things from The Last Jedi from a different point of view," to quote Obi-Wan Kenobi. Nevertheless, what stands out to me about these elements is how subtle and well-executed they are. Nothing in The Rise of Skywalker ever flatly contradicts or even dismisses anything from The Last Jedi. Nothing ever feels forced or as though it's only there in the film in order to revisit something from the previous film. If anything, most of these moments are so well executed that they make it seem as though they were always the direction that Rian Johnson's outing was planning to take them in the first place. In fact, I would say that on balance The Rise of Skywalker honors The Last Jedi more than it re-frames it, for those two major themes mentioned above (your identity does not define you and those who do what is right are never alone) are two of the closing thoughts that Johnson leaves viewers with in his film. The Rise of Skywalker may indeed "amend" a few things from The Last Jedi, but in the end, more than anything it builds on the direction and message that that middle installment took us in all while doing so in a way that should more than please The Last Jedi's critics.
The Rise of Skywalker is not a perfect film. There are a few plot threads that seem to have been dropped or forgotten about, although these are nothing major. There is also one moment in particular towards the end of the film which seems like a genuinely bad example of fan service, one which I think the film would be far better off without, but I can say that, knowing about it and dreading it going in, the rest of the film is so good that I think in the end it's only a minor annoyance that didn't detract at all from my enjoyment of the film. There are some force powers introduced which on the surface don't seem to make a lot of sense, although if you think about them enough I think they can be explained (which ameliorates the problem but is nevertheless really not ideal). It also does a disservice to Kelly Marie Tran by relegating her character to very much the background of the story. Indeed she's hardly present and could be removed altogether without changing anything else about the film. Part of the problem is that her character never really seemed to have a purpose in the first place, and this film is very tight, leaving little room for that which doesn't factor into the story it's trying to tell. Still, if she was going to be established as a major character in the previous film this one probably should have done something with her. I have read in many other reviews that the first half of the film has too rapid a pace or that it moves too quickly from one sequence to another. I could not disagree more, and in fact my wife and I both felt that the worst part of the film was when the pace briefly slows down in the first half.
On the whole, The Rise of Skywalker is an outstanding film when taken on its own. When taken as the final word on a nine-film saga which began with an all-time cultural phenomenon, it is not perfect but it is still very much a satisfying conclusion. I hate to keep comparing it to the other Disney era films because it is worthy of being spoken of on its own, but I know that this is the context in which many will think of it. The Rise of Skywalker is far more substantive than The Force Awakens, so those who found that film to be empty or to be a rehash of the original trilogy ought to find much more to chew on here. Those who hated The Last Jedi should find a lot to like in this film and should find it much more to their liking, but at the same time those who enjoyed that film should be able to see this one as a natural progression. I would already place it above all of the prequel films - which some may not regard as a significant accomplishment - and even perhaps above one or more of the original three films - which most would regard as quite an accomplishment. I doubt many will share my opinion in ranking this film quite so highly as to displace any of the original trilogy, but in the end the point is that even if not everyone ranks it quite so highly as I do, it is nevertheless a very strong film which is worth your time and which deserves a place in the pantheon of the more beloved of the Star Wars films.
Saturday, December 28, 2019
Thursday, August 16, 2018
The Mass as a Sacrifice
One of the greatest difficulties Protestants have with the
Catholic Church is the teaching that the Mass is a propitiatory sacrifice. The Church does teach that the Mass is a real
and true sacrifice, a sacrifice which propitiates for sins because it is the
sacrifice of Christ who alone can make propitiation for sins. The idea that the Mass is a propitiatory
sacrifice is offensive to Protestants for three primary reasons. First, it seems to suggest that Christ’s
offering on the cross was insufficient to save us from our sins. Second, because Christ is the victim in the
sacrifice of the Mass, it seems to require Him to die again and again. Finally, another difficulty Protestants have
is that the Scriptures clearly teach that Christ was sacrificed once for all
(Heb 7:25-27, 9:24-26, 10:10-14). One thing to consider about this last
objection is that the phrase ‘once for all’ is a shortened statement of one of
two things. It could either mean once for all time, or it could mean
once for all people. The phrase itself doesn't specify. In fact, the adverb used here does not
actually say once for all, but simply 'once.' Translators put "for
all" in to clarify the statement,
but it is really reading into the text.
Nevertheless, it is still a troubling point for most Protestants.
Bishop Fulton Sheen, a popular televangelist of the 1960s and
1970s, once said that there were not one hundred people in America who
hated the Catholic religion, but there were countless who hated what they
mistakenly thought the Catholic religion to be.
If Catholicism really were what these people thought it was, he pointed
out, Catholics would hate it too. This
statement is especially significant here.
Each of these objections is founded on a misunderstanding of what the
Catholicism teaches about the Mass. This misunderstanding is that the Mass is a different sacrifice from the cross. In fact, it is not. The Mass is understood to be the very same
sacrifice of the cross re-presented in a different manner:
“[Christ], our Lord and God, was
once and for all to offer himself to God the Father by his death on the altar
of the cross, to accomplish there an everlasting redemption. But because his priesthood was not to end
with his death, at the Last Supper “on the night when he was betrayed,” [he
wanted] to leave to his beloved spouse the Church a visible sacrifice (as the
nature of man demands) by which the bloody sacrifice which he was to accomplish
once and for all on the cross would be re-presented, its memory perpetuated
until the end of the world, and its salutary power be applied to the
forgiveness of the sins we daily commit.”(Council of Trent Session 22, Chapter
1)
“And since in this divine sacrifice
which is celebrated in the Mass, the same Christ who offered himself once in a bloody
manner on the altar of the cross is contained and offered in an unbloody
manner, the holy Synod teaches… this sacrifice is truly propitiatory…. The victim is one and the same: the same now
offers through the ministry of priests, who then offered himself on the cross;
only the manner of offering is different.”(Council of Trent Session 22, Chapter
2)
There are many other important things to consider in these
quotations. One is that the sacrifice of
the Mass exists because Christ’s priesthood was not to end with his death. This is a point which is explained by Hebrews
7:23-24:
The former priests were many in number, because they were prevented
by death from continuing in office, but he holds his priesthood permanently,
because he continues forever.
Another point is that the Mass is an unbloody sacrifice: Christ
does not die again in the sacrifice. Most people tend to think of a sacrifice
as a death, as though it is the death of the sacrificial victim which
constitutes a sacrifice. Therefore, it is
common for the sacrifice of Christ to be reduced to His death alone. However, the death of the victim is only the
first part of a sacrifice, with the presentation of the sacrifice being the
second, more important, part. If an Old Covenant priest had slain an animal and
then failed to present it to God, there would have been no sacrifice. Christ's sacrifice was presented to the
Father when His risen body ascended into Heaven, and is continually presented
so long as Christ is there in Heaven with the Father. The death of Christ was
in our time, but the presentation is not and can not be by definition.
Simply by being present in Heaven, Christ is presenting Himself to
the Father. Hebrews 9:24 makes reference to this, saying, “For Christ has
entered… into heaven itself, now to appear in the presence of God on our
behalf.” This is why the book of Hebrews
says that Christ “is able to save to the
uttermost those who draw near to God through him, since he always lives to make
intercession for them.” (7:25) This
intercession is not a different work from the sacrifice. It can't be,
because that would mean that His sacrifice was not sufficient. Protestant
commentators stress this point. The
intercessory work of Christ is not a different work from His sacrifice; it is
part of the sacrifice. It is the eternal
presentation of Christ before the Father. This appearing as a perpetual
presentation is so that He can perpetually be propitiation for our sins, as 1
John 2:1-2 says.
My little children, I am writing
these things to you so that you may not sin. But if anyone does sin, we have an
advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous. He is the propitiation
for our sins, and not for ours only but also for the sins of the whole world.
The verb 'is' here in “He is propitiation” is in the present
tense, meaning that Jesus is currently the propitiation. Protestant Greek
commentators are often very perplexed by this because they cannot understand
how Christ could currently be propitiation, since Protestant theology
understands Christ’s sacrifice on the cross to be the only propitiation for
sins. It is correct to understand
Christ’s sacrifice as the only propitiation for sins. However, it is incorrect to understand the
death on the cross to in and of itself be the sacrifice. It is because Christ’s sacrifice consists of
both the death on the cross and His
eternal presentation to the Father that John can write that He is currently the propitiation for sins.
The
eternality of Christ’s presentation is made clear by other Scriptures as
well. As was already cited, Hebrews 9:24
says that Christ “now” appears in the presence of God “on our behalf.” There is the ongoing work of intercession in
Hebrews 7:25, intercession which is a part of His sacrificial work. In Revelation 5:6,
He is depicted as “a lamb, standing as though slain. He is in Heaven a slain lamb, a sacrificial
victim, yet He is standing because He is risen.
Heaven is not bound by time, it is in eternity. Hence, elsewhere
in Revelation He is called the "lamb slain
before the foundation of the world" (Rev. 13:8). The reason John can say He was slain before
the foundation of the world even though He clearly died at a given moment in
the first century is because His sacrifice is an eternal one, a sacrifice which
is in its Heavenly part (the presentation) present in eternity. For this reason, men like Moses and Elijah,
who appeared at the transfiguration, could be saved even though Christ had not
yet died. The propitiation of Christ’s
sacrifice is eternally present in Heaven and thus was efficacious even for men
living before the incarnation. Hebrews
4:3 works along the same theme, stating that God's works were completed
"from the foundation of the world." The Mass is no more contradicting
the once for all nature of Christ's offering than His earthly death on the
cross was contradicting the fact that God's work was already done before the
foundation of the world, and that Christ was already slain before the
foundation of the world.
For Christ has entered, not into
holy places made with hands, which are copies of the true things, but into
heaven itself, now to appear in the presence of God on our behalf. Nor was it
to offer himself repeatedly, as the high priest enters the holy places every
year with blood not his own, for then he would have had to suffer repeatedly
since the foundation of the world. But as it is, he has appeared once for all
at the end of the ages to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself.
It is the suffering which
occurred once for all, never to be repeated. Christ's once for all offering, however, is perpetual and
eternal. In fact, it could even be said that the reason it is once for all is
because it is eternal; one cannot repeat something which has no beginning and
no end. Given all of the statements the
Scriptures make concerning the eternality of Christ’s presentation, it is clear
that Hebrews cannot possibly mean that Christ's offering was a one time,
momentary act. Rather, it is the
suffering which was a one time and momentary occurrence, which is why the
writer to the Hebrews explicitly states that Christ’s suffering would have been
required to happen again were He to be sacrificed again.
When the writer to the Hebrews speaks of the offering in this
passage, he is referring specifically to the high priest having to go in and
out of the Holy of Holies. That is why he writes, "Nor was it to offer
himself repeatedly, as the high priest enters the holy places every year
with blood not his own." That is also another reason why he emphasizes
the suffering so much. When sacrifices were made in the Old Covenant, the
priest would slaughter the animal outside of the Holy of Holies and then enter
into it. It was by the blood of this slaughtered animal that the priest could
enter the Holy of Holies, so if Christ were to go in and out of the Heavenly
Holy of Holies, He would have to suffer each time, but He does not, because
"he entered once for all into the holy places, not by means of the
blood of goats and calves but by means of his own blood" Once Christ
is in the Holy of Holies, His presence before the Father is the presentation of
the sacrifice to the Father. The actual
killing of the animal in the Old Covenant was only part of the sacrifice - the
other part was the presentation, which Jesus accomplished at the Ascension.
The Mass is a Sacrifice because it re-presents that eternal
sacrifice by making it present on the altar of the Church. The Sacrifice of the Mass is simply the
ongoing, eternal offering of Christ in Heaven. Hebrews is such an important book in terms of
the Mass because it was written to explain the superiority of the New Testament
sacrifice to the old sacrifices, and in chapter 8 it provides further insight
into the nature of the Mass:
Now the point in what we are saying
is this: we have such a high priest, one who is seated at the right hand of the
throne of the Majesty in heaven, a minister in the holy places, in the true
tent that the Lord set up, not man. For every high priest is appointed to offer
gifts and sacrifices; thus it is necessary for this priest also to have
something to offer. (1-3)
Even though He is sitting down, Christ is still a minister. He is
still offering that one sacrifice which is made once for all; otherwise He
would no longer be a minister. In fact, the passage makes this clear by stating
that it is necessary for Him to have something to offer. Just like ‘is’ in 1 John 2:2, the verb ‘have’
is present tense, meaning it is
currently occurring: Christ currently
must have something to offer. (If He had only had something to offer at one
time, an aorist or more likely a perfect tense would have been used.) This
passage teaches that Christ's offering is going on even now, and that He is
still ministering at the Heavenly altar.
It is this present offering which is made at the altar at the Mass. This is the altar
Hebrews refers to in saying, “we have an altar from which those who serve the tent have
no right to eat.” (13:10) This reference
to the priests of the Old Covenant having no right to eat at this altar shows
that the writer had in mind an earthly altar on which this sacrifice was
presented. He could not have meant, by
referring to eating from this altar, to be speaking symbolically of spiritually
receiving Christ or the salvation His sacrifice earned, because these priests had
as much a right to receive these things as those who were receiving them. All persons have as the same right to
salvation through Christ. (In fact as
Christians we understand that nobody has a right to salvation, but nonetheless
all who come to Christ in faith may receive it). There truly is an altar which Christians
alone may eat from, and this is the altar of the Mass.
The
only text that still may seem problematic for the doctrine of the Mass is
Hebrews 10:10-14:
And by that will we have been sanctified through the offering of the
body of Jesus Christ once for all. And every priest stands daily at his
service, offering repeatedly the same sacrifices, which can never take away
sins. But when Christ had offered for all time a single sacrifice for sins, he
sat down at the right hand of God, waiting from that time until his enemies
should be made a footstool for his feet. For by a single offering he has
perfected for all time those who are being sanctified.
Some
believe that because this passage teaches that Christ is sitting and waiting,
He cannot be offering an eternal sacrifice as the doctrine of the Mass
teaches. However, as has been pointed
out, Christ presents Himself to the Father simply by being present in
Heaven. In fact, He could not be in
Heaven and without presenting Himself
to the Father, because He is there in eternity as a slain lamb (Rev 13:8).
The problem with verse 14 is that it doesn't translate into
English well at all. The Greek text says, literally, “For by a single
offering He has perfected into continuity the being sanctified.” The Greek word that is translated in most Bibles as
"those who are being sanctified" is αγιαζομενους (agiazomenous), a present passive
participle. It is a verb form being used as a noun substantive. The actual word
doesn't actually include ‘those’ or ‘the ones’ or anything of that sort. It is
translated into English with those words added so that it makes sense in English.
The Greek language uses participles like this quite often, but they do not
translate well. In the original
language, the verse says only that the process of being sanctified is perfect. Αγιαζομενους,
the being sanctified, is in the accusative case, which means that it is the
object of the verb ‘perfected.’ However, the verb 'perfected' does not apply to
the "those who are" or "the ones who are"; it only applies
to "the being sanctified," the process of sanctification which is
applied to the ‘those.’ This is taught
by Hebrews because in the Old Covenant, a person could offer all the proper sacrifices
for sins, they could do everything they were required to and the process could
fail because it was imperfect. This verse teaches that the process now is
perfect thanks to the sacrifice of Christ and will not fail as long as a person
remains in the process. This is perfect given that overall theme of Hebrews of the
superiority of the New Covenant sacrifice over the sacrifices of the Old
Covenant.
That the Mass is a re-presentation of the eternal sacrifice of
Christ is also evident from the Last Supper accounts. The last supper was the Passover meal.
Passover meals, then as now, had a very specific "program." This
would involve the reading of particular Scriptures, singing of particular
hymns, and the consecration and drinking of four cups of wine. The Gospels
record this meal progressing as normal. The third cup was the one Christ raised
and said, "This is the New Covenant in my blood."(Luk 22:20) This can
be seen by studying the gospel accounts and because Paul refers to the cup of
the Lord's Supper as "the cup of blessing" in the first letter to the
Corinthians (10:16), which was the name given to the third cup of the Passover
meal. After this, the Passover called for the singing of a hymn (called the
Great Hallel, which consists of Psalms 114-118) before drinking from the fourth
cup, which was called the "cup of consummation."
However, Jesus didn't drink from the fourth cup. Instead, the gospels say that after blessing the third cup, Jesus specifically said He was not going to drink wine again until He did so “anew in the Kingdom of God.” (Mark 14:25) Immediately after this it says that "when they had sung a hymn, they went out to theMount of Olives ."
(25) This would have been a major
defect in the Passover meal, not a minor omission. The fourth cup was so important that the
Passover meal was not complete until it was drunk. After this, in Gethsemane ,
Jesus asks the Father to let the cup pass from Him (Matthew 26:39). When
a no doubt very thirsty Jesus was offered wine while carrying the cross up to
the mountain, He refused (Mark 15:23). Jesus
finally drank vinegar (a type of wine) from the hyssop branch and said "it
is consummated" at the moment of His death. The ‘it’ meant the Passover
meal. That Passover meal which He had began the previous night and never
finished He was now complete. It could
not have ended until then, because the fourth cup of wine had yet to be drunk.
However, Jesus didn't drink from the fourth cup. Instead, the gospels say that after blessing the third cup, Jesus specifically said He was not going to drink wine again until He did so “anew in the Kingdom of God.” (Mark 14:25) Immediately after this it says that "when they had sung a hymn, they went out to the
The
sacrifice was not begun on Calvary . Calvary
began with the Passover and the Passover ended with Calvary (see A Father
who Keeps His Promises, Scott Hahn, Servant Books 1998, p. 234; a more
thorough analysis of the above facts is also available therein) This ties
together a number of items which pertain to the Last Supper and its having been
a Mass.
First is the sacrificial language Jesus used during the Last Supper. The Greek word translated ‘remembrance’ in Luke 22 and 1 Corinthians 11 is anamnesis, which has great sacrificial overtones. There are at least 9 other Greek words for ‘remembrance’ which could have been used, however this sacrificial word was chosen instead. In fact, anamnesis can literally mean ‘memorial sacrifice’; it is used this way in the Greek Old Testament and is often translated this way in English Bibles. Hebrews 10:3, where it is also used in a sacrificial context, is the only place in which the word is used in the New Testament: "But in these sacrifices there is a reminder of sin every year." The passage would actually make much more sense if anamnesis were translated as it is in the Old Testament here, so that it would read: "But in these is a memorial sacrifice for sin every year." In fact, in the original Greek it does not say "but in those sacrifices," because the word ‘sacrifices’ is not in the text. It is added because without it the passage makes no sense in English. Rendering the word consistently here cleans up the passage immediately, cutting the need for translators to add words to Scripture. The Greek word for "do" used in these passages, ‘poiein,’ is also a word with sacrificial overtones, used over 75 times in the Old Testament to mean ‘offer.’ It would be a completely accurate translation of 1 Corinthians 11:23 (and Luke 22:19) to render Jesus' words as "offer this as a memorial sacrifice of me," and in fact, Jewish readers who were very familiar with the Septuagint would very likely have understood it this way.
Second is the Jewish understanding of the Passover meal. Many Jewish traditions believed that those who were eating the Passover were not simply remembering the first Passover, but were literally taking part in the literal, one time event of the first Passover. They were understood to be literally taking part in the Exodus as if they were there themselves inEgypt following Moses to the
promised land. This is extremely
interesting because the redemption is extremely parallel to the Exodus. There
are countless parallels. This is because the Exodus from physical bondage was a
foreshadowing of the true Exodus from spiritual bondage that is found in
Jesus Christ. Jesus is called
the Lamb of God because He is the Passover lamb that was sacrificed to save the
firstborn from death. When a person
enters into Christ through baptism, he or she becomes a child of God (Mat. 5:9,
5:45, Luk 6:35, 20:36, John 12:36, Rom. 8:14-15, 8:23, 9:26, 2 Cor 6:18, Gal.
3:26, 4:5-6, Heb. 12:7-8) The paschal
sacrifice of the lamb saved the lives of the firstborn of the people of God
during the first Passover, and now the sacrifice of the Lamb of God saves the
lives of all children of God.
First is the sacrificial language Jesus used during the Last Supper. The Greek word translated ‘remembrance’ in Luke 22 and 1 Corinthians 11 is anamnesis, which has great sacrificial overtones. There are at least 9 other Greek words for ‘remembrance’ which could have been used, however this sacrificial word was chosen instead. In fact, anamnesis can literally mean ‘memorial sacrifice’; it is used this way in the Greek Old Testament and is often translated this way in English Bibles. Hebrews 10:3, where it is also used in a sacrificial context, is the only place in which the word is used in the New Testament: "But in these sacrifices there is a reminder of sin every year." The passage would actually make much more sense if anamnesis were translated as it is in the Old Testament here, so that it would read: "But in these is a memorial sacrifice for sin every year." In fact, in the original Greek it does not say "but in those sacrifices," because the word ‘sacrifices’ is not in the text. It is added because without it the passage makes no sense in English. Rendering the word consistently here cleans up the passage immediately, cutting the need for translators to add words to Scripture. The Greek word for "do" used in these passages, ‘poiein,’ is also a word with sacrificial overtones, used over 75 times in the Old Testament to mean ‘offer.’ It would be a completely accurate translation of 1 Corinthians 11:23 (and Luke 22:19) to render Jesus' words as "offer this as a memorial sacrifice of me," and in fact, Jewish readers who were very familiar with the Septuagint would very likely have understood it this way.
Second is the Jewish understanding of the Passover meal. Many Jewish traditions believed that those who were eating the Passover were not simply remembering the first Passover, but were literally taking part in the literal, one time event of the first Passover. They were understood to be literally taking part in the Exodus as if they were there themselves in
There are many other parallels as well.
Like the Passover lamb, Christ was to be without blemish (Ex 12:5 / Heb
9:14). The Passover lamb was examined on
the 14th day of Nisan to ensure that it was unblemished, and Christ was
examined on the 14th day of Nisan with no fault being found in Him (Luke 23:4,14;
John 18:38; 19:4,6) The Passover lambs’
bones were not to be broken, just as Christ’s bones were not broken (Ex 12:46,
Num. 9:12 / John 19:36) The blood of the
Passover lamb was put on the posts of the Israelite’s doors, and the blood of
Christ was put on the post of the cross. (Ex 12:7) There are other parallels beyond this, and
many other connections that are not strictly parallel. For instance, it was a hyssop branch that was
to be used to spread the blood of the Passover lamb, and it was a hyssop branch
that was used to give Jesus a drink of wine on the cross (Ex 12:22 / John
19:29).
Other traditional Jewish aspects of the Passover were also incorporated
into the sacrifice of Christ and the Last Supper. One example is the breaking of the Afikoman,
which is the second of three cakes of unleavened bread which were eaten during
the Passover meal. In many Jewish
traditions, the bottom cake was understood to represent Abraham, the top cake
to represent Jacob, and the middle cake, the Afikoman, to represent Isaac.
While God stopped Abraham from sacrificing his son Isaac, (Gen 22:10-12)
the Father Himself did allow His son to be sacrificed. It was the Afikoman that would have
been broken during the Passover celebration when Christ broke bread, saying,
“This is my body which is given for you.” (Luke 22:19) The Mass extends this parallel, because just
as the Afikoman was broken and all would eat a piece of the one bread
during the Passover, so too is the Eucharist, the
body of Christ, broken and given to all to eat during the Mass.
In fact, the parallel between the sacrifice of Christ and the Passover
makes it necessary that Christians eat of Christ’s body, because the Passover
lamb was required to be eaten by all after its sacrifice and no part left over.
(Ex 12:8-10, 34:25, Num. 9:12) Therefore
Paul writes, “Christ our Passover lamb is sacrificed for us: therefore let us
keep the feast...” (1 Cor 5:7-8)
Jesus' sacrifice began at the Last Supper, and was the eternal
Passover sacrifice that can be experienced today through a literal participation
at the sacrifice of the Mass, just as the ancient Jews literally participated
in the Exodus by their Passover meal. The Last Supper was the first Mass in which
Christ first made present on Earth His eternal sacrifice. (More information on the Last Supper being
the beginning of Christ’s sacrifice can be found here.)
God Bless,
Shane Coombs 2006
Monday, April 09, 2018
Pharisaism and the New Pro-Lifers
It’s become quite common over the past year or two to see
articles, social media posts and comments, and other forms of expression
declaring that “You can’t be pro-life and…” Exclusions include everything from “pro-death
penalty,” “pro-torture,” “anti-immigration,” or “anti-welfare” to “pro-gun,” “pro-war,”
and “alt-right.” When it’s not phrased according to the “you can’t be…” formula,
the sentiment comes as an admonition or call out of those who claim to be
pro-life but scandalously advocate some farther right view of one of these
issues. There’s no question that opposing torture, taking care of the poor,
etc. are important to the support of life, especially for someone coming from a
Christian background.
It’s also common see the terms “pharisee” or “pharisaism” come
up in commentary or discussions of this topic. Make no mistake: this is always
a serious charge to throw around. After all, the Pharisees were on the
receiving end of Jesus’ strongest criticism and serve as some of the chief
antagonists of Christ in the Gospels. Their crime? “Hypocrites!” Jesus
declared, for the Pharisees did not always practice what they preached. They were
also known for getting into people’s business, harshly demanding the strictest
adherence to the rules and to the law. “They tie up heavy burdens, hard to
bear, and lay them on people’s shoulders, but they themselves are not willing
to move them with their finger” (Mat. 23:4). The Pharisees’ merciless approach
was particularly hard on the poor, who often lacked the resources to fulfill the
last letter of the law, the vulnerable, and those whose past mistakes had put
them in difficult positions.
It makes perfect sense, then, to see accusations of pharisaism
in this debate. So many of the items at hand here involve the same kinds of
people that the Pharisees of Jesus’ day. Torture and the death penalty have as
their focus the vulnerable (and indeed, law enforcement and peace keeping too
often perpetrate injustices against vulnerable populations). Immigration and
welfare policies impact the poor and the vulnerable. Those who rightly stand up
for the lives of the unborn, one vulnerable group, but callously discount
concern for the lives of other vulnerable groups are certainly being
inconsistent. These new pro-lifers, as we might call them, have a point in
admonishing and calling out inconsistencies and hypocrisy on these points.
But there’s something important that these new pro-lifers (and many others) miss about the Pharisees. Most people know that the Pharisees were merciless taskmasters who enforced a very strict adherence to the rules and the law, but far fewer know why they did this. The Pharisees emerged in a time when Judea was only a tiny province within the Roman Empire, making both imperial law and pagan culture obstacles to the practice of the Jewish faith. Their raison d'être was to find a way for the Jews to remain faithful to God under these living conditions and ultimately to be free of the Romans and have their independence once again. Unlike the Sadducees, who favored compromise with the Romans, the Essenes, who practiced total withdrawal from worldly affairs, and the zealots, who saw violent rebellion as the only answer, the Pharisees believed that God Himself would deliver them to freedom once more as He had done in the past – but with one critical caveat: the Jewish people needed to be pure – all of them (or at least almost all).
But there’s something important that these new pro-lifers (and many others) miss about the Pharisees. Most people know that the Pharisees were merciless taskmasters who enforced a very strict adherence to the rules and the law, but far fewer know why they did this. The Pharisees emerged in a time when Judea was only a tiny province within the Roman Empire, making both imperial law and pagan culture obstacles to the practice of the Jewish faith. Their raison d'être was to find a way for the Jews to remain faithful to God under these living conditions and ultimately to be free of the Romans and have their independence once again. Unlike the Sadducees, who favored compromise with the Romans, the Essenes, who practiced total withdrawal from worldly affairs, and the zealots, who saw violent rebellion as the only answer, the Pharisees believed that God Himself would deliver them to freedom once more as He had done in the past – but with one critical caveat: the Jewish people needed to be pure – all of them (or at least almost all).
This belief is the reason that the Pharisees were so strict
and so unwilling to show mercy or compassion. In their understanding, the
Jewish people were suffering under the Romans as a punishment for their
unfaithfulness and only when they had returned to faithfulness would God
relent. This did make sense, after all: it was a pattern and theme which
repeated over and over throughout the entire history of the Hebrew people,
notably in the books of Judges, Samuel, Chronicles, and Kings. The Pharisees
were so demanding and unyielding not because they were just callous or for
whatever reason instinctively authoritarian, but because they saw every failure
to keep even the smallest point of the Mosaic law as one more weight on the
scale of judgment angering God and keeping him from freeing them of oppression.
They insisted on separating themselves from the rest of the culture (indeed,
this is precisely where we get the word “Pharisee” from) and rejected any
imperfection or compromise not just as a personal sin, but as something which
would be imputed to their entire people. This isn’t to attempt to rehabilitate
the Pharisees or to defend their failure to grasp the spirit of the law,
something for which Jesus strongly rebuked them. The point is that the
Pharisees were severe in demanding total purity of their fellow Jews because
they viewed anything less as contributing to keeping the intolerable status quo
in place – which brings us back to the new pro-lifers.
While any pro-lifer is to be lauded for standing up for the
rights of the poor or the displaced or for rejecting torture, it is a trend of
late to see the new pro-lifers go further than this. To many, not only are
those who have imperfect views on the broader spectrum of issues to be
corrected, but they are to be denied the pro-life name, to be excluded, and to
have even their positive contributions be disavowed. Like the Pharisees, the
new pro-lifers demand purity from anyone who would bear the name with any
shortcomings viewed as mortally harmful to the movement. Those who oppose
abortion and may even hold consistent views on most other issues are often demonized
as the reason that the pro-life movement has not been more successful. Lest we dismiss
the comparison to the Pharisees is too tenuous, bear in mind that it is common
to hear or to read these new pro-lifers warn that God will not grant success to
the movement so long as such persons are welcome in their ranks.
One need look no further for an example of this than Donald Trump and his supporters. While Trump is far from the perfect example of a consistent pro-life ethic, he nevertheless received strong support from large percentages of the pro-life electorate for whatever he would be able to offer. He may not have been perfect, but to many he was better than the alternative. To some pro-lifers, this was viewed as very questionable. It was unclear just how trustworthy he’d be, for one thing, and even if he followed through his inconsistencies may harm the public image of the pro-life movement. These were reasonable concerns. Far less reasonable and more in line with the thinking of the Pharisees were those new pro-lifers who went further, condemning any who would vote for Trump as “not pro-life,” as putting party over principle, and as drawing the ire of the Almighty onto the country by electing such a man.
One need look no further for an example of this than Donald Trump and his supporters. While Trump is far from the perfect example of a consistent pro-life ethic, he nevertheless received strong support from large percentages of the pro-life electorate for whatever he would be able to offer. He may not have been perfect, but to many he was better than the alternative. To some pro-lifers, this was viewed as very questionable. It was unclear just how trustworthy he’d be, for one thing, and even if he followed through his inconsistencies may harm the public image of the pro-life movement. These were reasonable concerns. Far less reasonable and more in line with the thinking of the Pharisees were those new pro-lifers who went further, condemning any who would vote for Trump as “not pro-life,” as putting party over principle, and as drawing the ire of the Almighty onto the country by electing such a man.
Trump is one example, but the stakes need not be so grand:
this kind of truly pharisaical thinking has become common to see in all sorts
of contexts. Worst of all is when this kind of exclusion and condemnation
concerns not black and white matters of objective morality but prudential
judgments about methods. A person might believe in the need to provide for the
poor but reject a particular legislative proposal as a good or effective way to
do it. Like the Pharisees who were so focused on the letter of the law that
they could not see the spirit, too many new pro-lifers cannot see the good
faith of such a person or try to understand their view, but see them only through
the jots and tittles of the policy that they have questioned.
In his encyclical Deus
Caritas Est, Pope Benedict XVI made clear that Catholics should work together
with people of other faiths where improving the temporal world is concerned. A
Catholic and a Protestant can work together to feed the hungry, while a Jewish
person is a good an ally in fighting a worldly injustice despite theological
differences. That doesn’t mean these differences don’t matter or even that they
may not in some ways impact mutual work in the temporal sphere. Such
differences need to be acknowledged and taken into consideration, but the
ultimate goal is still to be pursued. In a similar way, pro-lifers who
recognize weaknesses and imperfections in the views of others should
acknowledge them and try to address them, but they must also recognize these persons
as the allies that they can be in the ways that they can be.
Too many Christian pro-lifers today have come to regard
imperfect allies as bitter enemies. Like the Pharisees, they view them as
traitors, as repellants to Divine aid, and even as greater obstacles than the
worldly powers which have us under their power. This is a tragic trend which
must stop.
Thursday, February 15, 2018
About the Gravity of Lenten Fasting and Abstinence
I recently saw a reply to question about the gravity of fasting and abstinence during Lent in which a priest said that it is not a sin to violate Lenten abstinence and fasting requirements, but this is not correct. Moreover, the reasoning that he gave for this answer is demonstrably incorrect. He wrote: "In order for a merely disciplinary norm to be binding on pain of sin, the legislator has to make it so. The legislator (i.e., John Paul II, who issued the 1983 Code of Canon Law) has made the Sunday obligation gravely binding (hence a grave sin if deliberately disobeyed). He decided *not* to do so for the fasting and abstinence laws. Therefore, it does not bind on pain of sin. It is similar in status to the rule that religious congregations have."
The controlling document in this case is Paul VI’s apostolic constitution Paenitemini, which says of the days of penance, "Their substantial observance binds gravely." You point to the 1983 Code of Canon Law as essentially abrogating this prior law, but the Code of Canon Law is very specific about what prior laws are abrogated in Canon 6:
"1. the Code of Canon Law promulgated in 1917;" - Paenitemini was not part of this code
"2. other universal or particular laws contrary to the prescripts of this Code unless other provision is expressly made for particular laws;" - The law as given in Paenitemini is not contrary to anything in the 1983 code. If there are any doubts about this, see the final few paragraphs about the US Bishops’ judgment on the question.
"3. any universal or particular penal laws whatsoever issued by the Apostolic See unless they are contained in this Code;" - Paenitimini did not address penal law
"4. other universal disciplinary laws regarding matter which this Code completely reorders" - The 1983 Code does not completely reorder the laws of fasting and abstinence (indeed, even debates about the controversial question of whether fasting is obliged on Fridays throughout the year always center of Paul VI's Paenitimini and documents which appeal to it's authority. Whether a person argues that Friday abstinence is required year- round or not, that person is always pointing to Paenitimini because it is still the document of legal force on these matters.) Again, see below on the US Bishops, who even note that parts of Paenitimini are "almost identical" to the Code.
As Jimmy Akin notes, "In fact, the Code has so little to say about penance that one cannot determine what the Church’s law is without consulting Paenitemini. For example, the Code does not provide any explanation of what the law of fast entails. It states who is subject to it (Can. 1251), but it does not explain what the law itself is. To find that out, you have to consult Paenitemini." (Canon 1251 does give some more detail about the law of abstinence, but Jimmy is correct: if we want to know anything about what the Church means when legislating that we must fast, we need to look at the Apostolic Constitution. If we don’t consider Paenitimini, then we don’t know whether fasting means no food at all, eating only once, eating as usual but lighter, etc. The “one full meal and two snacks” thing comes – albeit in corrupted form – from Paenitimini.
In it's information on fasting and abstinence, the USCCB itself still points to it's own 1966 Pastoral Statement on the topic because although coming before the 1983 code, everything in it is, having been based on Paenitimini and not on Canon law (either 1917 or the then-not-yet written 1983 code), still relevant.
Even the 1983 code of canon law uses the language of binding, such as in canon 1252 which reads, "The law of abstinence binds those who have completed their fourteenth year."
All of this should be sufficient evidence, but the US Bishop's 1983 Complementary Norms to Canon 1253 provide perhaps the clearest. The complementary norm 1) Refers to Paenitemini as authoritative, 2) Appeal to Paeitimini's authority to support the changes that the US Bishop's wanted to make to age requirements for fasting, and 3) Explicitly declares that the US Bishop's 1966 norms, which are based on Paenitimini and which say that Lenten fast/abstinence binds under pain of sin, are not contrary to the 1983 code and so do not fall under Canon 6 as provided above.
The US Bishops' 1966 document, which recall is unquestionably still legally binding and confirmed by their 1983 complementary norms, also says: " In keeping with the letter and spirit of Pope Paul's Constitution Poenitemini, we preserved for our dioceses the tradition of abstinence from meat on each of the Fridays of Lent, confident that no Catholic Christian will lightly hold himself excused from this penitential practice." [Emphasis added]
Thus, AT A MINIMUM, Lenten penance binds under pain of sin in the United States. This is explicit according to the Bishops' 1966 norms which are confirmed in the 1983 complementary norms to remain in force. However, based on all of the reasons given above it should be quite clear that Paenitimini remains in force for the entire Latin Church - a belief certainly held by the US Bishops' Conference - and the Bishops' norms really just confirm this for us more than anything.
God bless
The controlling document in this case is Paul VI’s apostolic constitution Paenitemini, which says of the days of penance, "Their substantial observance binds gravely." You point to the 1983 Code of Canon Law as essentially abrogating this prior law, but the Code of Canon Law is very specific about what prior laws are abrogated in Canon 6:
"1. the Code of Canon Law promulgated in 1917;" - Paenitemini was not part of this code
"2. other universal or particular laws contrary to the prescripts of this Code unless other provision is expressly made for particular laws;" - The law as given in Paenitemini is not contrary to anything in the 1983 code. If there are any doubts about this, see the final few paragraphs about the US Bishops’ judgment on the question.
"3. any universal or particular penal laws whatsoever issued by the Apostolic See unless they are contained in this Code;" - Paenitimini did not address penal law
"4. other universal disciplinary laws regarding matter which this Code completely reorders" - The 1983 Code does not completely reorder the laws of fasting and abstinence (indeed, even debates about the controversial question of whether fasting is obliged on Fridays throughout the year always center of Paul VI's Paenitimini and documents which appeal to it's authority. Whether a person argues that Friday abstinence is required year- round or not, that person is always pointing to Paenitimini because it is still the document of legal force on these matters.) Again, see below on the US Bishops, who even note that parts of Paenitimini are "almost identical" to the Code.
As Jimmy Akin notes, "In fact, the Code has so little to say about penance that one cannot determine what the Church’s law is without consulting Paenitemini. For example, the Code does not provide any explanation of what the law of fast entails. It states who is subject to it (Can. 1251), but it does not explain what the law itself is. To find that out, you have to consult Paenitemini." (Canon 1251 does give some more detail about the law of abstinence, but Jimmy is correct: if we want to know anything about what the Church means when legislating that we must fast, we need to look at the Apostolic Constitution. If we don’t consider Paenitimini, then we don’t know whether fasting means no food at all, eating only once, eating as usual but lighter, etc. The “one full meal and two snacks” thing comes – albeit in corrupted form – from Paenitimini.
In it's information on fasting and abstinence, the USCCB itself still points to it's own 1966 Pastoral Statement on the topic because although coming before the 1983 code, everything in it is, having been based on Paenitimini and not on Canon law (either 1917 or the then-not-yet written 1983 code), still relevant.
Even the 1983 code of canon law uses the language of binding, such as in canon 1252 which reads, "The law of abstinence binds those who have completed their fourteenth year."
All of this should be sufficient evidence, but the US Bishop's 1983 Complementary Norms to Canon 1253 provide perhaps the clearest. The complementary norm 1) Refers to Paenitemini as authoritative, 2) Appeal to Paeitimini's authority to support the changes that the US Bishop's wanted to make to age requirements for fasting, and 3) Explicitly declares that the US Bishop's 1966 norms, which are based on Paenitimini and which say that Lenten fast/abstinence binds under pain of sin, are not contrary to the 1983 code and so do not fall under Canon 6 as provided above.
The US Bishops' 1966 document, which recall is unquestionably still legally binding and confirmed by their 1983 complementary norms, also says: " In keeping with the letter and spirit of Pope Paul's Constitution Poenitemini, we preserved for our dioceses the tradition of abstinence from meat on each of the Fridays of Lent, confident that no Catholic Christian will lightly hold himself excused from this penitential practice." [Emphasis added]
Thus, AT A MINIMUM, Lenten penance binds under pain of sin in the United States. This is explicit according to the Bishops' 1966 norms which are confirmed in the 1983 complementary norms to remain in force. However, based on all of the reasons given above it should be quite clear that Paenitimini remains in force for the entire Latin Church - a belief certainly held by the US Bishops' Conference - and the Bishops' norms really just confirm this for us more than anything.
God bless
Friday, July 03, 2015
My response to Matthew Vines' 40 Questions
Matthew Vines has posted 40 questions for Christians who oppose same-sex marriage, and while I do not normally do this sort of thing, I realized in reading through that many of my answers, especially about my personal relationships, are likely different from how Matthew expects people to be answering. Therefore, I thought I would complete his entire questionnaire.
1. Do you accept that sexual orientation is not a choice?
Yes.
2. Do you accept that sexual orientation is highly resistant to attempts to change it?
I am willing to grant this point. I know that there are protocols which are reported by some to have a high success rate in changing sexual orientation, but I do not have the time or expertise to dig too deeply into this material. Even if it were demonstrated that sexual orientation were easily alterable, it is unlikely that more than a small proportion of persons experiencing same-sex attraction would be interested in changing it, and so there is really no relevance to considering it here.
3. How many meaningful relationships with lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender (LGBT) people do you have?
I have had several very meaningful relationships with LGBT persons in my life. Four stand out as what I would call close friendships. Of these, three are persons that I currently talk to infrequently because of the natural flow of life – people grow older, graduate school, get jobs, move away, etc. The fourth is one of my current closest friendships.
4. How many openly LGBT people would say you are one of their closest friends?
As of the current time, one. See #3.
5. How much time have you spent in one-on-one conversation with LGBT Christians about their faith and sexuality?
Hours upon hours upon hours. Upon hours.
6. Do you accept that heterosexual marriage is not a realistic option for most gay people?
Certainly.
7. Do you accept that lifelong celibacy is the only valid option for most gay people if all same-sex relationships are sinful?
Yes.
8. How many gay brothers and sisters in Christ have you walked with on the path of mandatory celibacy, and for how long?
Several. Of the close friends I mentioned in #3, two were gay Christians. All told, I have spent years with them. There are several other gay Christians who I would not consider to be among my closest friends but who I have also had some form of relationship with for years.
9. What is your answer for gay Christians who struggled for years to live out a celibacy mandate but were driven to suicidal despair in the process?
My response for and to such persons would be the same response that I would have to anyone who is driven to suicidal despair. This would include heterosexual persons who have suffered despair or suicidal thoughts or feelings because they were forced to live in *involuntary* celibacy owing to being unable to find romantic partners. It would also include the homosexual persons who suffer suicidal inclinations because they wish to live out a life of Christian celibacy and feel rejected by the gay community over their choice. Yes – this is a real phenomenon. The fact is that suicidal thoughts or feelings or temptations are not a matter of the circumstances in our lives. They are a matter of depression, a mental illness which affects people of all walks and all beliefs in all circumstances. It is, quite simply, ill-informed and insensitive to speak about suicide as you have in your question, as though it were simply a response to having a difficult path to walk.
10. Has mandatory celibacy produced good fruit in the lives of most gay Christians you know?
In every case, the answer is yes. That includes three people that I know personally, and several others who I know only through acquaintances or my church community. That celibate gay Christians that I know are in many ways the most faithful, most devout, most knowledgeable, and most generous Christians that I know. And, in case you thought to ask, yes, I would say that their discipline of celibacy has actually helped to build up these fruits and has not simply come alongside.
11. How many married same-sex couples do you know?
I do not personally know any same-sex couples.
12. Do you believe that same-sex couples’ relationships can show the fruit of the Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control?
Yes. The Holy Spirit can work in anyone of us at any time. In the Old Testament, the Spirit prophesied through Balum as he actively tried to destroy the Israelites. In the New Testament, the Spirit worked through the High Priest as well, even though he was working to have Jesus killed. In the book of Acts, the Holy Spirit worked through people who had not yet even become Christian. The reality is that the Holy Spirit works through all people and all situations as long as we do not put up roadblocks to it. This is also the case in bad situations or in sinning persons. “God can write straight with crooked lines” is the old saying. In a same-sex relationship, the Spirit will work whatever good He can, even if there is something problematic about the relationship itself. This is, as I have hopefully demonstrated, how God approaches all people and situations.
13. Do you believe that it is possible to be a Christian and support same-sex marriage in the church?
This is somewhat of a complicated question because it depends on what is meant by the term “Christian.” Obviously, it’s necessary to draw a line somewhere in terms of what beliefs one may hold and rightly be called a Christian. For example, can a person who believes Jesus never existed be considered a Christian simply because he self-identifies as such? I think that most would easily answer in the negative here, but where precisely is then the line is drawn? Different Christian communities will have different answers.
It gets a bit more complicated because of the difference theologies of salvation, justification, and sanctification that different Christian communities have. Given a person who professes faith in Christ and even many doctrines of the Church but rejects some other doctrines, some theologies would say that such a person is not a member of the Church because we are once-saved-always-saved and the person’s rejection of a key doctrine would preclude him from salvation and therefore he must not have ever been a part of the Church. Others would say that his faith in Christ is all that is necessary, and others would fall in between or even have entirely different answers to the question.
As a Catholic, I would say that any baptized person is a member of the Church and therefore a Christian, but that those who reject doctrines of the Church are not currently in communion with the Church and not “living members.” They are united to the Church in virtue of their baptism and so they are Christians, but in their support of same-sex marriage (or slavery, as per #14) they have cut themselves off from the sanctifying and life-giving power of Christ and the Church.
Put more concisely, Christians can sin. In fact, Christianity has always taught very strongly that Christians will sin as we are fallen creatures. There is no contradiction between supporting same-sex marriage or slavery or murder or countless other things and holding the name Christian, but in doing so such Christians sin.
It gets a bit more complicated because of the difference theologies of salvation, justification, and sanctification that different Christian communities have. Given a person who professes faith in Christ and even many doctrines of the Church but rejects some other doctrines, some theologies would say that such a person is not a member of the Church because we are once-saved-always-saved and the person’s rejection of a key doctrine would preclude him from salvation and therefore he must not have ever been a part of the Church. Others would say that his faith in Christ is all that is necessary, and others would fall in between or even have entirely different answers to the question.
As a Catholic, I would say that any baptized person is a member of the Church and therefore a Christian, but that those who reject doctrines of the Church are not currently in communion with the Church and not “living members.” They are united to the Church in virtue of their baptism and so they are Christians, but in their support of same-sex marriage (or slavery, as per #14) they have cut themselves off from the sanctifying and life-giving power of Christ and the Church.
Put more concisely, Christians can sin. In fact, Christianity has always taught very strongly that Christians will sin as we are fallen creatures. There is no contradiction between supporting same-sex marriage or slavery or murder or countless other things and holding the name Christian, but in doing so such Christians sin.
14. Do you believe that it is possible to be a Christian and support slavery?
See #13.
15. If not, do you believe that Martin Luther, John Calvin, and Jonathan Edwards were not actually Christians because they supported slavery?
See #13.
16. Do you think supporting same-sex marriage is a more serious problem than supporting slavery?
Both same-sex marriage and slavery are offenses against the dignity of the human person made in the image and likeness of God, and so I do not see either as being especially more serious.
17. Did you spend any time studying the Bible’s passages about slavery before you felt comfortable believing that slavery is wrong?
While I am studied on a great deal of what the Bible says, this is not a question which holds a great deal of meaning for me as I had already converted to Catholicism before the question of slavery really occurred to me, and as Catholics the Bible is interpreted in the context of each book’s literary genre and the teaching of the Church.
18. Does it cause you any concern that Christians throughout most of church history would have disagreed with you?
This is the first of several instances in which your Church history is quite simply incorrect. While many of the Protestant reformers and those who followed after them supported slavery for some time, dating back to the earliest Christians chattle slavery (the kind that was prevalent in the United States until the Civil War and which is under discussion here) was not widely supported.
When Christianity first came into existence, it lacked the social power to eliminate all slavery, but Christians did what they could to improve the life of slaves by making sure that they were treated well, were kept together with their families, and were even paid. There are many records of newly converted Christian slaveowners freeing their slaves. Several of the first popes were even former slaves. Early Christian writers such as St. Gregory of Nyssa (c. 330) and St. John Chrysostom (c. 349) condemned slavery. Early Church councils in 452, 506, 511, 517, 538, 549, 585, 589, 615, 633, and many others promulgated legislation about the rights of slaves, including in some cases prohibition of slave trafficking. This is a very, very brief picture and I encourage you to do more research, but suffice it to say that you are greatly mistaken on this point.
When Christianity first came into existence, it lacked the social power to eliminate all slavery, but Christians did what they could to improve the life of slaves by making sure that they were treated well, were kept together with their families, and were even paid. There are many records of newly converted Christian slaveowners freeing their slaves. Several of the first popes were even former slaves. Early Christian writers such as St. Gregory of Nyssa (c. 330) and St. John Chrysostom (c. 349) condemned slavery. Early Church councils in 452, 506, 511, 517, 538, 549, 585, 589, 615, 633, and many others promulgated legislation about the rights of slaves, including in some cases prohibition of slave trafficking. This is a very, very brief picture and I encourage you to do more research, but suffice it to say that you are greatly mistaken on this point.
19. Did you know that, for most of church history, Christians believed that the Bible taught the earth stood still at the center of the universe?
Just as in #18, you are at least somewhat mistaken on this point. There certainly were Christians throughout history who believed in geocentrism and geostationism, but they didn’t get it from the Bible. They believed in it based on what contemporary science (loose though the term may be) taught. David Palm, a traditionalist Catholic who has written extensively on the subject, has been unable to identify more than ten writers throughout the entire Patristic period of Christianity (about the first 700 years) who mention geocentrism or geostationism, and of these none cite the Bible or even Christian tradition regarding this belief, while several of them cite mathematicians and natural philosophers (primitive forms of scientists).
This is consistent with the way that early Christians wrote about nature and the faith. To the early Christians, the Scriptures taught, as the saying goes, “how to go to heaven, not how the heavens go.” St. Augustine of Hippo (c. 400) is a fairly standard citation of this belief. Even Copernicus, who was supported by the Pope and the Church as he helped to pioneer the theory of heliocentrism about a hundred years before Galileo, declared that the Bible did not teach geocentrism.
Yet even if you were unconvinced by this, it is still not relevant. See the answer to #20.
This is consistent with the way that early Christians wrote about nature and the faith. To the early Christians, the Scriptures taught, as the saying goes, “how to go to heaven, not how the heavens go.” St. Augustine of Hippo (c. 400) is a fairly standard citation of this belief. Even Copernicus, who was supported by the Pope and the Church as he helped to pioneer the theory of heliocentrism about a hundred years before Galileo, declared that the Bible did not teach geocentrism.
Yet even if you were unconvinced by this, it is still not relevant. See the answer to #20.
20. Does it cause you any concern that you disagree with their interpretation of the Bible?
Even if I believed that historical Christians believed in geocentrism and geostationism, it would not be concerning or relevant because as a Catholic I do not believe that the Bible teaches matters of scientific fact, but that teaches facts on matters of faith and morals. See #19 and #21.
21. Did you spend any time studying the Bible’s verses on the topic before you felt comfortable believing that the earth revolves around the sun?
Just as in the case of # 17, this question has little meaning to me because while I am familiar with the Bible’s verses which are sometimes alleged to teach geocentrism, but I have also been aware since almost the beginning of my acceptance of Christianity that that they were not interpreted this way until certain Protestant groups did so in relatively modern times. For example, there are many extant Scriptural commentaries from early Christianity, and to my knowledge none of them speak to any Scriptural passages as having anything to do with the physical motion of the Earth and/or the Sun.
22. Do you know of any Christian writers before the 20th century who acknowledged that gay people must be celibate for life due to the church’s rejection of same-sex relationships?
In the early Church there were debates about whether or not all Christians were required to practice lifelong celibacy. Even after it was settled that this was not the case, lifelong celibacy was still required in many parts of the Church for widows and widowers for some years, and when it was finally settled that this was unnecessary, celibacy was still promoted for centuries as the Christian ideal, and was always mandatory for western priests and for all bishops. The We also see plenty of statements that those who are separated from their spouses – even if the separation is involuntary or unjust - must remain celibate for life. In some places in early Christianity, marriages had to be approved by one’s bishop before they could be celebrated, and this permission was sometimes denied.
This should be sufficient to answer the question, because it establishes that there is very much a tradition in Christian history holding at least some persons to mandatory celibacy, even when it is not voluntarily chosen.
To this, we can add the countless writers - many of the same who wrote of preferred or mandatory celibacy - who condemned homosexual relationships. The understanding of a homosexual orientation as a fundamental reality to a person’s existence is of course relatively new. Throughout most of Christian history, people simply didn’t understand it in this way, and so the writers who do condemn homosexuality tend to look at it as some kind of moral condition or disorder more than a psychological or biological reality. They didn’t understand it as a lifelong intrinsic reality, and so expecting an explicit statement about lifelong celibacy is not reasonable in the same way that it would be unreasonable for an anti-vaxxer to ask for historic Christian statements on the morality of vaccinations because historic Christians had no concept of vaccines.
What would be more reasonable would be to look at the way that historic Christians viewed disease and medical treatment in general and then apply those principles to vaccinations in order to get a sense of what historic Christians would have thought about them. In fact, the connections between lifelong celibacy for gay Christians and historic Christian writings are far, far more direct than the connections would be if looking for those pertaining to vaccines, or the internet, or carbon pollution, or any number of other things.
Quite simply, early and historic Christians unanimously believed that lifelong celibacy was a difficult but mandatory cross for any person who could for whatever reason not be in a legitimate marriage. This includes gay couples, because they also unanimously believed that two persons of the same sex could not be in a legitimate marriage.
23. If not, might it be fair to say that mandating celibacy for gay Christians is not a traditional position?
See #22. Also, turn the question around and recognize that permitting marriage between members of the same sex is nor a traditional position. It is ultimately a self-defeating argument.
24. Do you believe that the Bible explicitly teaches that all gay Christians must be single and celibate for life?
The Bible explicitly teaches that marriage is the union of a man and a woman. It also explicitly teaches that celibacy is the only option for those who do not enter into marriage. Therefore, by the laws of logic, it does explicitly teach that all gay Christians must be celibate for life. If you are unsatisfied with this level of explicitness, it is worth noting that the Bible does not explicitly teach that God is Triune and consists of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. It does not explicitly teach what books make up the canon of the Bible itself. It does not explicitly teach many things that all Christians unanimously believe. Many of them are implicit or require exegesis. See #25.
25. If not, do you feel comfortable affirming something that is not explicitly affirmed in the Bible?
I am very comfortable affirming something that is not explicitly affirmed in the Bible. As a Catholic, I believe that God reveals Himself through Scripture and through Sacred Tradition. Part of this Sacred Tradition is the very list of the Biblical Canon itself.
26. Do you believe that the moral distinction between lust and love matters for LGBT people’s romantic relationships?
This question really gets to the heart of the issue. Unfortunately, I am not going to try to invest a lot of time unpacking my answer because it would take far too much time. For reference, I have a 700 page book on my bookshelf which just goes a tad below the surface of this idea. What I will say is this:
As a Catholic, I believe that marital love is a total self-giving of one person to his or her spouse which admits to holding nothing back, whereas lust is any use of one’s sexuality whichdoes hold something back. This includes giving one’s gift of fertility to the other. This means that contraception or fellatio, for example, would constitute lust, for it would seek to receive some of the goods of sexuality while holding back the fertility of a person. In the same way, two men or two women who engage sexually by their very nature cannot give their fertility to one another. Rather, we are called to follow Christ’s words that it is the giving of one’s very life – of everything one has – to another which constitutes love. Even when a person’s fertility is old or damaged and no longer functions, sexual intercourse between spouses can still offer it in whatever state it is in, in a way that homosexual orcontracepting relations cannot.
If you would like to learn more about this, look into the “Theology of the Body.” There are many books, articles, and videos available to dig into it in far, far more depth than is possible here.
As a Catholic, I believe that marital love is a total self-giving of one person to his or her spouse which admits to holding nothing back, whereas lust is any use of one’s sexuality whichdoes hold something back. This includes giving one’s gift of fertility to the other. This means that contraception or fellatio, for example, would constitute lust, for it would seek to receive some of the goods of sexuality while holding back the fertility of a person. In the same way, two men or two women who engage sexually by their very nature cannot give their fertility to one another. Rather, we are called to follow Christ’s words that it is the giving of one’s very life – of everything one has – to another which constitutes love. Even when a person’s fertility is old or damaged and no longer functions, sexual intercourse between spouses can still offer it in whatever state it is in, in a way that homosexual orcontracepting relations cannot.
If you would like to learn more about this, look into the “Theology of the Body.” There are many books, articles, and videos available to dig into it in far, far more depth than is possible here.
27. Do you think that loving same-sex relationships should be assessed in the same way as the same-sex behavior Paul explicitly describes as lustful in Romans 1?
In one sense, yes, because homosexual behavior is intrinsically lustful as per the answer to #26. However, there is another sense in which we can certainly acknowledge an important distinction between a committed same-sex couple and other lustful behavior. Some Christians regard morality as having no place for degree or circumstances. As a Catholic, I do not believe this.
So, for example, even though I regard all unmarried sex as a sin, sex between a committed but unmarried heterosexual couple is better than sex between a heterosexual couple in a one-night stand. Both are gravely sinful, but in the case of the committed couple, there is present some additional good and right intention which is lacking in the one-night stand. Similarly, a man who steals a toy to give to his child is sinning, but it is still better than a man who steals something for himself. In the same way, a committed homosexual couple would have some good that is lacking in a homosexual couple which met at a bar one night before having sex. This goes back to the principle from # 12 that God can do good even in the midst of evil.
So, for example, even though I regard all unmarried sex as a sin, sex between a committed but unmarried heterosexual couple is better than sex between a heterosexual couple in a one-night stand. Both are gravely sinful, but in the case of the committed couple, there is present some additional good and right intention which is lacking in the one-night stand. Similarly, a man who steals a toy to give to his child is sinning, but it is still better than a man who steals something for himself. In the same way, a committed homosexual couple would have some good that is lacking in a homosexual couple which met at a bar one night before having sex. This goes back to the principle from # 12 that God can do good even in the midst of evil.
28. Do you believe that Paul’s use of the terms “shameful” and “unnatural” in Romans 1:26-27 means that all same-sex relationships are sinful?
Yes. In using the term unnatural, St. Paul goes beyond the specific situation in question and addresses the fundamental nature of same-sex sexual relation itself. If one were to talk about something which was sinful in virtue of the circumstances rather than some intrinsic problem, then one would not use the term “unnatural.” For example, nobody would call a man having sex with another man’s wife “unnatural,” even though it was sinful and lustful.
29. Would you say the same about Paul’s description of long hair in men as “shameful” and against “nature” in 1 Corinthians 11:14, or would you say he was describing cultural norms of his time?
He is making a statement about what is natural and unnatural just as in Romans, but we misunderstand it because of differences in cultural norms – so both, and neither!
There are two factors to consider here. The first is that cultural norms are different as to just what constitutes long hair. For example, based on a variety of Scripture passages it is likely that St. Paul himself wore hair that would be considered long for a man by today’s standards. Jesus may have as well, if as some suggest he at some point took a Nazarite vow. Therefore, St. Paul is certainly not condemning as unnatural hair as one may see on some men today. The second is that in this passage, St. Paul did not use the typical Greek word for hair, θριξ. Rather, he used another word, κομάω, which seems to have referred in particular to a particular style of tresses worn by women.
In short, his point was that it is unnatural for men to make themselves look like women.
30. Do you believe that the capacity for procreation is essential to marriage?I would not use the term “capacity.” Rather, I would say that marriage is ordered toward procreation. Describing it the way you have in your question has an emphasis which is like saying that one wants to have a marriage and asking what the bare minimum requirements are to “get in,” whereas describing it the way that I have and that Catholic philosophers have tended to has an emphasis which is more about asking what marriage is for before deciding whether or not we want to enter into one.
Think of it like two different couples meeting with a pastor as to plan their wedding. One couple is asking the pastor, “If we get married, do we have to have kids?” The second is asking, “If we want to have kids, should we get married?” Big difference!
Think of it like two different couples meeting with a pastor as to plan their wedding. One couple is asking the pastor, “If we get married, do we have to have kids?” The second is asking, “If we want to have kids, should we get married?” Big difference!
31. If so, what does that mean for infertile heterosexual couples?
Not every instance of an act which is ordered toward some end has to actually achieve that end to maintain its purpose and ordering. A batter swinging at a pitch may miss, but the act he is engaged in is still an act which is designed to hit the ball. A little league batter may go up against a major league pitcher and have absolutely no chance to actually succeed, but his swinging of the bat is still the right thing to do at the plate. On the other hand, a person who stood in the batter’s box grilling a steak wouldn’t be doing something ordered toward hitting the ball, nor would a .350 major league hitter swinging the bat while standing on third base.
An infertile or post-menopausal couple making love are still doing an act which is by its nature ordered toward procreation, even if in their case that act won’t actually procreate, just as are a fertile couple making love outside of the woman’s ovulatory period. Of course, the little leaguer could, by the grace of God, manage to actually get a hit against the major league pitcher, and sometimes infertile or theoretically post-menopausal couples do in fact conceive.
An infertile or post-menopausal couple making love are still doing an act which is by its nature ordered toward procreation, even if in their case that act won’t actually procreate, just as are a fertile couple making love outside of the woman’s ovulatory period. Of course, the little leaguer could, by the grace of God, manage to actually get a hit against the major league pitcher, and sometimes infertile or theoretically post-menopausal couples do in fact conceive.
32. How much time have you spent engaging with the writings of LGBT-affirming Christians like Justin Lee, James Brownson, and Rachel Murr?
I am not familiar with these authors. However, I have read the works of LGBT Christians such as David Morrison, Eve Tushnet, and Steven Gershom, who oppose gay marriage. I have also viewed documentaries like The Third Way or Desire of the Everlasting Hills (which gay friends tell me they think is better) featuring of gay Christians who oppose gay marriage. Have you?
I am not familiar with these authors. However, I have read the works of LGBT Christians such as David Morrison, Eve Tushnet, and Steven Gershom, who oppose gay marriage. I have also viewed documentaries like The Third Way or Desire of the Everlasting Hills (which gay friends tell me they think is better) featuring of gay Christians who oppose gay marriage. Have you?
33. What relationship recognition rights short of marriage do you support for same-sex couples?
The same recognitions that any non-married persons have. Notably, the recognition as human beings who deserve to be treated with love and respect.
34. What are you doing to advocate for those rights?
I do not believe that there are many legal rights to advocate for, seeing as all non-married persons already have them. That said, I will certainly speak out and, if necessary, take action against any persecution or hatred toward gay persons, as I would against persecution or hatred toward anybody. I also make an effort to admonish fellow Christians and others who do not treat gay persons with love and respect any time the need arises.
35. Do you know who Tyler Clementi, Leelah Alcorn, and Blake Brockington are, and did your church offer any kind of prayer for them when their deaths made national news?
Off the top of my head, I do not. Of course, I could easily produce a list of names of persons who died from violence, persecution, or suicide who I am sure you would not know off the top of your head, either. We unfortunately hear these kinds of stories every day on the news. However, I can assure you that if I did at any time hear or read about their deaths that I prayed for them and their families, as I do for all deaths that I hear about, especially deaths that come from injustice. I am also quite certain that the Catholic Church has offered prayers for them, as Catholic parishes regularly include public cases such as this in their prayer intentions.
Off the top of my head, I do not. Of course, I could easily produce a list of names of persons who died from violence, persecution, or suicide who I am sure you would not know off the top of your head, either. We unfortunately hear these kinds of stories every day on the news. However, I can assure you that if I did at any time hear or read about their deaths that I prayed for them and their families, as I do for all deaths that I hear about, especially deaths that come from injustice. I am also quite certain that the Catholic Church has offered prayers for them, as Catholic parishes regularly include public cases such as this in their prayer intentions.
36. Do you know that LGBT youth whose families reject them are 8.4 times more likely to attempt suicide than LGBT youth whose families support them?No LGBT or any other person should suffer rejection from their families, whether their families agree with everything that they do or not. I know Christian families who have had gay children and have made sure that those children feel loved. This is the only approach acceptable for Christians.
37. Have you vocally objected when church leaders and other Christians have compared same-sex relationships to things like bestiality, incest, and pedophilia?I would not vocally object to these kinds of comparisons, because these kinds of comparisons have their place. Of course, I have also compared same-sex relationships to lesser sins that all of us fall into, such as lying and jealousy, in order to point out to people that we should not view people in same sex relationships as though they are the greatest sinners in the world as St. Paul does, after all, list them amidst things like jealousy. I have most often compared them to heterosexual relationships involving pre or extramarital sex.
Noting similarities between two things is not the same thing as declaring moral equivalency between them. In cases where people have compared same sex relationships to things like the practice of bestiality or the indulgence in pedophilia with the intention of creating a moral equivalency – that is, with the intention of saying that they are just as bad – I have objected.
I must note how in your question you talk about the act of participating in same sex relationships while you talk about the inclination to pedophilia. This is an important distinction because most Christians who oppose same sex marriage would accept that gay persons are not be responsible for their sexual orientation (as per #1), just as pedophiles are not responsible for their pedophilia. Both are responsible for their actions alone.
Noting similarities between two things is not the same thing as declaring moral equivalency between them. In cases where people have compared same sex relationships to things like the practice of bestiality or the indulgence in pedophilia with the intention of creating a moral equivalency – that is, with the intention of saying that they are just as bad – I have objected.
I must note how in your question you talk about the act of participating in same sex relationships while you talk about the inclination to pedophilia. This is an important distinction because most Christians who oppose same sex marriage would accept that gay persons are not be responsible for their sexual orientation (as per #1), just as pedophiles are not responsible for their pedophilia. Both are responsible for their actions alone.
38. How certain are you that God’s will for all gay Christians is lifelong celibacy?Completely. It is not an easy calling, but we are all called to carry our crosses. Some of our crosses can be extremely difficult, but God's grace is sufficient, and we have a God who suffered for and with us, and provides an answer to our suffering in the form of Himself on the cross.
39. What do you think the result would be if we told all straight teenagers in the church that if they ever dated someone they liked, held someone’s hand, kissed someone, or got married, they would be rebelling against God?Such an approach would likely prompt either a very negative or a very apathetic response. In fact, this is the result that we tend to see in the Church when we tell not only teens, but just about everyone else about any moral issue. People do not like to hear moral admonitions, and they generally react angrily or with apathy towards the faith. In the general Christian community it is only a select few who are willing to bear all of the crosses that life gives to them.
The difference, of course, is that one’s sexuality is an incredibly integral part – indeed, from a Catholic point of view, the integral part – of the human person. This means that approaching this particular issue in a callous way would have much, much stronger, painful, and harmful results. There is no question that same sex attraction and the call to lifelong celibacy is a cross – and a very difficult one to bear.
This is why, for example, the Catholic Church (and many other Christian churches) approach this issue not by speaking about what God forbids, but about the gift of integral sexuality that God calls us to. We speak about what God has to give us, and the calling to goodness that it is. Ministries such as Courage, an international organization of and for homosexual Catholics trying to live out Christ’s call to celibacy and sexual integrity are extremely important. Did you know that it exists? http://www.couragerc.org.
The difference, of course, is that one’s sexuality is an incredibly integral part – indeed, from a Catholic point of view, the integral part – of the human person. This means that approaching this particular issue in a callous way would have much, much stronger, painful, and harmful results. There is no question that same sex attraction and the call to lifelong celibacy is a cross – and a very difficult one to bear.
This is why, for example, the Catholic Church (and many other Christian churches) approach this issue not by speaking about what God forbids, but about the gift of integral sexuality that God calls us to. We speak about what God has to give us, and the calling to goodness that it is. Ministries such as Courage, an international organization of and for homosexual Catholics trying to live out Christ’s call to celibacy and sexual integrity are extremely important. Did you know that it exists? http://www.couragerc.org.
40. Are you willing to be in fellowship with Christians who disagree with you on this topic?If by this you mean to ask whether I am willing to have personal Christian fellowship with them, the answer is of course. If you mean maintain a communion of Churches, the answer is more complicated, but it is not limited to gay marriage. The Catholic Church does not consider itself to be in communion with Churches which disagree onany issue. However, they will of course maintain a positive relationship with such communities.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



